Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New?
Author: Erik H.
Date: 01-09-2018 - 19:33

Question Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Would a series of giant signs as follows have prevented this accident?

Maybe the question is, are the currently installed speed restriction signs adequate in terms of position, size, color, etc.?

The MUTCD has very specific rules about the size of a sign and its placement. The railroads set their own signing policies; the speed sign that is installed on this track follows the BNSF standard and appears to be a 18" wide by 12" tall sign - the size of a standard "No Parking" sign. Now, imagine you're travelling down I-5 at 70 MPH. Do you think you're going to be able to see that sign?

To put it in perspective, those green milepost signs posted every mile along a freeway are at least twice as big...

Also, a lot can happen at two miles. How many highway warning signs are positioned two miles back? None. Again, the MUTCD specifies a set distance - a sign prescribing a reduction in speed from 70 MPH to 30 MPH would be positioned 450 feet prior to the restriction. Now trains for obvious physical reasons need more time to slow down, but is two miles necessary or even appropriate?



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  New NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 OPRRMS 01-09-2018 - 15:11
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 jst3751 01-09-2018 - 16:11
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? BOB2 01-09-2018 - 16:43
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? WILL 01-09-2018 - 16:56
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? BOB2 01-09-2018 - 17:45
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? OPRRMS 01-09-2018 - 17:41
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Question 01-09-2018 - 17:47
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Mark 01-09-2018 - 17:50
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Did anyone call the speed restriction when they passed it? BOB2 01-09-2018 - 18:01
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Joe M. 01-09-2018 - 19:35
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? B6b 01-09-2018 - 19:58
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? tundraboomer 01-09-2018 - 20:17
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? B6b 01-09-2018 - 20:46
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Dr Zarkoff 01-09-2018 - 22:53
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? theconductor 01-10-2018 - 08:36
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? david vartanoff 01-09-2018 - 22:59
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? OPRRMS 01-09-2018 - 22:00
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Erik H. 01-09-2018 - 19:33
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? David.Curlee 01-09-2018 - 21:21
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Dr Zarkoff 01-09-2018 - 22:35
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? David.Curlee 01-10-2018 - 02:09
  Re: New ? Speed Board??? Nudge 01-10-2018 - 17:48
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Dr Zarkoff 01-10-2018 - 20:17
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? Dr Zarkoff 01-09-2018 - 23:01
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? John Bruce 01-10-2018 - 09:36
  Re:And you're not a synonym for stupid, with a really stupid comment like that? Just sayin' 01-10-2018 - 10:12
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501-Not Much New? OPRRMS 01-10-2018 - 10:23
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 OPRRMS 01-09-2018 - 17:39
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 Berg 01-09-2018 - 19:42
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? BOB2 01-10-2018 - 10:00
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? BOB R 01-10-2018 - 15:49
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? George Andrews 01-10-2018 - 16:26
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? A C-5 Bob BOB2 01-10-2018 - 17:08
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? Nudge 01-10-2018 - 17:54
  Re: Railfans versus Railroaders? Commenter 01-10-2018 - 18:07
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 jst3751 01-10-2018 - 09:57
  Re: New on Jan 4 NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 OPRRMS 01-10-2018 - 10:12
  Re: New NTSB update re: Amtrak 501 Thanks for the link. 01-10-2018 - 12:07


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please enter the code that you see below in the input field.
 **         ********   **    **  **     **        ** 
 **    **   **     **  ***   **  **     **        ** 
 **    **   **     **  ****  **  **     **        ** 
 **    **   ********   ** ** **  **     **        ** 
 *********  **     **  **  ****   **   **   **    ** 
       **   **     **  **   ***    ** **    **    ** 
       **   ********   **    **     ***      ******  
This message board is maintained by:
Altamont Press Publishing Company