Re: Or according to the latest reports, maybe we should blame the engineer....
Author: M. Harris
Date: 03-17-2018 - 19:32

If you look at the lower-panel cross-section at one end, you might notice the tensioning cables are in the upper part of the slab, not the lower. This suggests the slab was designed to resist bending from upward forces on the slab. This is consistent with the support that cable stays from a vertical pylon would provide. Since there was apparently nothing acting on the slab in an upward direction, such as would be the case with cable stays from a pylon after construction completion, or temporary falsework or supports during construction, all the tension in the slab tendons were acting to bend the structure downward in addition to the dead load of the structure. I think any tampering with the tension of the tendons that morning (as reported) could have contributed to starting the collapse. I think this structure had a critical erection schedule that the contractor failed to follow.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  Replacement 'pre-built' bridge fails; not RR bridge Graham Buxton 03-15-2018 - 12:56
  . . 03-15-2018 - 14:20
  Re: Tkme to go to the Ashmolian and ask Wren to recalculate the loading? BOB2 03-15-2018 - 15:33
  Re: Tkme to go to the Ashmolian and ask Wren to recalculate the loading? Aunt Blabby 03-15-2018 - 15:51
  Re: Tkme to go to the Ashmolian and ask Wren to recalculate the loading? Ed Workman 03-15-2018 - 15:59
  Miami, Florida, pedestrian bridge collapse kills several people Margaret (SP fan) 03-15-2018 - 17:22
  Re: Shouldn't blame the engineer....you're right. BOB2 03-15-2018 - 17:46
  Re: Shouldn't blame the engineer....you're right. Ed Workman 03-15-2018 - 18:08
  Re: Shouldn't blame the engineer....you're right. Ray Eiser 03-16-2018 - 02:04
  Re: Shouldn't blame the engineer....you're right. Agent 99 03-16-2018 - 08:15
  Re: Or according to the latest reports, maybe we should blame the engineer.... BOB2 03-16-2018 - 18:33
  Re: Or according to the latest reports, maybe we should blame the engineer.... M. Harris 03-17-2018 - 19:32
  Re: Another transit car order problem Nussel Snouts 03-16-2018 - 23:51
  Re: Replacement 'pre-built' bridge fails; not RR bridge OldPoleBurner 03-17-2018 - 22:11


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
       **  ********  **    **   ******   **     ** 
       **     **      **  **   **    **  ***   *** 
       **     **       ****    **        **** **** 
       **     **        **     **        ** *** ** 
 **    **     **        **     **        **     ** 
 **    **     **        **     **    **  **     ** 
  ******      **        **      ******   **     ** 
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com