Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why?
Author: mook lurking
Date: 08-12-2018 - 10:28

Like the others (CAF comes to mind), Nippon Sharyo will be back, briefly, if a big enough contract is offered. Unless things are ridiculously rigged (which has happened) re. Buy American, they could do it like they did back in the Fourth Age of Middle Earth, when Caltrain was just starting up and needed to replace all the old SP stuff with shiny new push-pull cars patterned after Metra's. Carbodies were built in Japan, shipped to a pier in SF where they were mated with running gear and interior parts mostly made in the US. One-shot, minimize facility cost, then leave. Some of those cars are still running, after almost 40 years. CAF did something similar for Sacramento's early-2000s light rail cars: set up an assembly plant at McClellan, assembled the cars using Spanish carbodies, and left with no other immediate work prospects. The only companies that seem to have made a go of US transit production over the long term are Siemens and Alstom, both of which do Real Railroad stuff as well as transit.

The problem with the one-shots is that they may be low-bid for construction (though we all know how that works out with politix and change orders), but there's little capability or desire for after-sale service. That leads to the companies that do stick around (aforementioned Siemens and Alstom) picking up a nice line in support/rehab for all sorts of stuff, not just their own. And being the only companies that can manufacture almost entirely in the US, they get a leg up on Buy American.

As Bob says, oh well...



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Clem 08-11-2018 - 10:31
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA synonymouse 08-11-2018 - 11:59
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Ed Workman 08-11-2018 - 13:45
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA synonymouse 08-11-2018 - 19:51
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Clem 08-11-2018 - 21:56
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA synonymouse 08-11-2018 - 23:08
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Graham Buxton 08-12-2018 - 06:02
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Ed Workman 08-12-2018 - 08:00
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 12:11
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Erik H. 08-11-2018 - 14:40
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Commenter 08-11-2018 - 15:34
  SMART Cloverdale??? Donaghy 08-11-2018 - 16:00
  Re: SMART Cloverdale??? john 08-12-2018 - 12:00
  Re: SMART Cloverdale??? Donaghy 08-12-2018 - 12:41
  Re: SMART Cloverdale??? Al Stangenberger 08-12-2018 - 14:17
  Re: SMART annexations Al Stangenberger 08-12-2018 - 15:12
  Re: SMART annexations Donaghy 08-12-2018 - 18:29
  Re: SMART annexations Al Stangenberger 08-12-2018 - 23:47
  Re: SMART Cloverdale??? 456 08-13-2018 - 00:08
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Smart cars David 08-11-2018 - 12:30
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Peter 08-11-2018 - 15:50
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA observer from afar 08-11-2018 - 17:33
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Donaghy 08-11-2018 - 19:26
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA Joe Magruder 08-12-2018 - 06:31
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? BOB2 08-12-2018 - 08:15
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? mook lurking 08-12-2018 - 10:28
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? Clem 08-12-2018 - 11:00
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 12:20
  Friction Stir Welding, not just Friction Welding Clem 08-12-2018 - 13:55
  Re: Friction Stir Welding, not just Friction Welding Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 16:27
  Re: Friction Stir Welding, not just Friction Welding Clem 08-12-2018 - 17:42
  Re: Friction Stir Welding, not just Friction Welding WebDigger 08-12-2018 - 20:43
  Re: Friction Stir Welding, not just Friction Welding Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 21:24
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? david vartanoff 08-12-2018 - 19:39
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 21:30
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? The Canuck 08-12-2018 - 22:06
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? George Andrews 08-13-2018 - 21:01
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? Peter 08-13-2018 - 22:29
  Re: Nippon Sharyo pulling out of USA- Why? Dr Zarkoff 08-16-2018 - 22:07
  BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? Donaghy 08-12-2018 - 12:52
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? synonymouse 08-12-2018 - 14:48
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 16:30
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? synonymouse 08-12-2018 - 18:13
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? Commenter 08-12-2018 - 15:04
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? Dr Zarkoff 08-12-2018 - 16:33
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMARt? Donaghy 08-12-2018 - 18:20
  Memories Commenter 08-12-2018 - 21:22
  Re: detour CLINT 08-13-2018 - 02:19
  Re: detour Orlo 08-13-2018 - 12:17
  Just build more ferries Margaret (SP fan) 08-13-2018 - 00:22
  Re: Just build more ferries Graham Buxton 08-13-2018 - 06:34
  Re: Does the Bay area hold the school record Ed Workman 08-13-2018 - 08:04
  Re: Does the Bay area hold the school record >> BART & AirTrain Graham Buxton 08-13-2018 - 08:19
  Re: Does the Bay area hold the school record >> BART & AirTrain Movin' along 08-13-2018 - 08:55
  Re: Does the Bay area hold the school record >> BART & AirTrain Clem 08-14-2018 - 19:48
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMART? BOB2 08-13-2018 - 08:31
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMART? Ed Workman 08-13-2018 - 09:08
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMART? BOB2 08-13-2018 - 09:34
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMART? WebDigger 08-13-2018 - 09:26
  Re: BOB2: What Do You Recommend to SMART? synonymouse 08-13-2018 - 12:33
  Re: No matter what happens, it will al be part of the vast conspiracy...... BOB2 08-13-2018 - 12:54
  Re: No matter what happens, it will al be part of the vast conspiracy...... synonymouse 08-13-2018 - 14:05


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **     **  ********   ********  ********        ** 
 **     **  **     **  **        **    **        ** 
 **     **  **     **  **            **          ** 
 *********  ********   ******       **           ** 
 **     **  **         **          **      **    ** 
 **     **  **         **          **      **    ** 
 **     **  **         ********    **       ******  
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com