I wonder how many people critiquing Kalmbach's map quality have ever tried to produce a publishable map? My guess is not many. Although I have spotted mistakes on the original version of the GN map, these were later corrected. I challenge people complaining about Trains Mag's maps to put up or shut up.

I am also a fan of John Signor's work, but many of his works are artistically stylized. Comparing these with Trains' maps is like comparing apples to oranges.