Re: Re:One of the Perfect People??? Never any TWC errors?
Author: mook
Date: 06-27-2009 - 10:28

Interesting that people are using the DC collision to rag on PTS or PTC. The systems are totally different. Problems found in the DC system cannot be connected in any way with the PTS/PTC systems being proposed for "real" railroads other than via a generalized Luddite tendency.

The DC system has Automatic Train Control, the trains normally run completely without driver involvement other than watching the doors at the stations to hold them a moment if somebody might get stuck, and the "detection" system is based on old-fashioned (with a few computerized updates) signal technology with additional detectors. That type of detection/signal system is used in one way or another in nearly every modern rail transit system that uses extensive private r/w, at least to run the signals and let "central" know where the trains are. Based on the news reports, the crash seems to have occurred because the detection system failed allowing the computer to try to drive a train through another one it didn't know was there. The driver apparently tried to stop using the "panic button" but there wasn't enough time, for whatever reason.

Per Google Maps, there are two Metro tracks at that station (the outside tracks are CSX/MARC), and the approach seems to be nearly straight for some distance. Can't tell, of course, where the trains actually were, but they do run pretty close together; in the Google satellite picture, one is in the Fort Totten station, and another is clear of the previous station on the way in. On one trip to DC I used their Metro, and in rush hour on the Red Line the trains were less than 2 minutes apart, so they definitely use the system to the limits of its design. I think the only comparable systems in terms of age and design are BART and LA's Red/Orange Line.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  NTSB press release re: DC Metro collision OPRRMS 06-25-2009 - 15:51
  Re: NTSB press release re: DC Metro collision That's just GREAT! 06-25-2009 - 17:07
  Re: NTSB press release re: DC Metro collision mook 06-25-2009 - 17:48
  Re: NTSB press release re: DC Metro collision Dr Zarkoff 06-25-2009 - 21:36
  Re: NTSB press release re: DC Metro collision Policespeeder 06-26-2009 - 04:44
  Re: NTSB; and what was the operator doing? C. Cutler 06-26-2009 - 08:35
  Reaction time Mike Stimpson 06-26-2009 - 09:20
  Re: Reaction time Steven D. Johnson 06-26-2009 - 09:32
  Re: Reaction time Roger 06-26-2009 - 09:44
  Re: Reaction time mook 06-26-2009 - 12:21
  Re: Reaction time Mike Swanson 06-26-2009 - 14:07
  Re: Reaction time See Above 06-26-2009 - 15:43
  Re: Reaction time G-man 06-26-2009 - 16:17
  Re: railroad forum no thanks 06-26-2009 - 17:33
  Re: NTSB thought positive train control was the cure all!!! Dwight Peterson 06-26-2009 - 18:08
  Re: NTSB thought positive train control was the cure all!!! BOB2 06-26-2009 - 20:48
  Re: NTSB thought positive train control was the cure all!!! Check this out 06-26-2009 - 23:15
  Re:One of the Perfect People??? Never any TWC errors? BOB2 06-27-2009 - 07:45
  Re: Re:One of the Perfect People??? Never any TWC errors? mook 06-27-2009 - 10:28
  Re: Re:One of the Perfect People??? Never any TWC errors? mook 06-27-2009 - 10:34
  Re: NTSB thought positive train control was the cure all!!! SP5103 06-27-2009 - 16:09


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
       **  **     **  **         **    **  ********  
       **  **     **  **    **    **  **   **     ** 
       **  **     **  **    **     ****    **     ** 
       **  **     **  **    **      **     ********  
 **    **  **     **  *********     **     **     ** 
 **    **  **     **        **      **     **     ** 
  ******    *******         **      **     ********  
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com