Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning
Author: SP5103
Date: 09-29-2016 - 17:01

There has always been a problem with short/light trains on signaled track. IIRC when RDCs first came out I think B&M had a bad wreck where a few RDCs stopped on sand and then got rear ended by a conventional train on a false clear.

The fewer the wheels and lighter the equipment, the more chance it may not consistently shunt the circuit. Some railroads have specific dispatcher rules for handling things like Sperry cars or trains/engines with a limited number of axles in signaled territory, the dispatcher reuired to further protect them.

Then again, there are plenty of LRT systems that seem to get their signals to work. Caltrain would not be comparable, whereas the Sprinter might be a better example. And remember they are trying to integrate a signal system, PTC and overlapping grade crossing approach circuits at the same time. It doesn't take much to screw things up. I wonder what penalty the contractors are facing, or if it is a design or component issue? That's the problem with today's version of transit railroading -it is far too complicated and the technology being demanded now isn't simple and proven.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning The Odd Duck 09-29-2016 - 13:55
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning clipper841 09-29-2016 - 14:36
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning SP5103 09-29-2016 - 17:01
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning Flakes 09-29-2016 - 17:39
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning synonymouse 09-29-2016 - 19:45
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning mook 09-29-2016 - 21:18
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning Rail 09-29-2016 - 23:42
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning The Odd Duck 09-30-2016 - 00:07
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning Dr Zarkoff 09-30-2016 - 01:06
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART rail warning devices malfunctioning Rasputin 09-30-2016 - 11:31
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART BART Nudge 09-30-2016 - 12:36
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART BART Espee99 09-30-2016 - 16:18
  Re: San Rafael, Novato SMART BART Dr Zarkoff 09-30-2016 - 20:54
  Re: SMART; BART; PTC Margaret (SP fan) 09-30-2016 - 20:21
  Re: SMART; BART; PTC Carol L Voss 09-30-2016 - 21:50
  Re: SMART; BART; PTC -- Thanks, Carol! :) Margaret (SP fan) 09-30-2016 - 23:46
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? BOB2 10-01-2016 - 09:45
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? SP5103 10-01-2016 - 14:27
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? mook 10-01-2016 - 19:09
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? Dr Zarkoff 10-01-2016 - 21:59
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? mook 10-01-2016 - 23:29
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? Dr Zarkoff 10-01-2016 - 18:31
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? OldPoleBurner 10-02-2016 - 21:29
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? Dr Zarkoff 10-02-2016 - 23:05
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? OldPoleBurner 10-05-2016 - 20:24
  Re: Doppler based RF signal activation? Dr Zarkoff 10-06-2016 - 12:21


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
  *******   **    **  ********  **    **  ******** 
 **     **   **  **   **        **   **   **       
 **     **    ****    **        **  **    **       
  ********     **     ******    *****     ******   
        **     **     **        **  **    **       
 **     **     **     **        **   **   **       
  *******      **     ********  **    **  ******** 
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com