Arcadia's books are more for a feeling of the area/railroad than for painstakingly researched history. They're basically personal recollections, which as we all know can be somewhat orthogonal to reality. That said, they do sometimes have photos not generally seen before. It would be nice if there were a way to get some of the more obvious errors I've seen in a few of their other books corrected, and if the printing job were a little clearer for some of the photos -- b/w that's sometimes very muddy. But then you're not paying $100 either.