Re: To hell with broad gauge
Author: fKrock
Date: 04-12-2016 - 11:39

If you will read contemporary trade journals you will find that many BART design features were the result of extensive research by competent engineers. They were not being different just for the sake of difference. For example, wind tunnel tests revealed a wider track gauge would give a smoother ride on elevated track structures in prevailing Bay Area winds. Each experimental increase improved ride up to about 5' 6". Beyond that width produced little improvement. So they decided that gauge would be cost effective. Since BART never intended to exchange cars with other railroads, incompatibility was no problem.

Other than things like track spikes, almost every thing for railroads is built to order. Almost nothing comes off the shelf. The additional steel used for wider gauge equipment was only a minute part of the cost.

The BART wheel contour was the result of experiments performed in house by the BART engineering staff; they cured truck hunting problems. So statements blaming Bechtel are more ignorant railfan babble. Unfortunately a lot of wrong information keeps being repeated. A lot of self- appointed experts and conspiracy theorists sound off.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-10-2016 - 22:32
  Re: To hell with broad gauge But look at them tapered wheels! 04-10-2016 - 23:21
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Good blog post 04-11-2016 - 08:11
  Re: To hell with broad gauge fkrock 04-11-2016 - 09:12
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Max Wyss 04-11-2016 - 10:01
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Dr Zarkoff 04-11-2016 - 10:47
  Re: To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-11-2016 - 11:24
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Max Wyss 04-11-2016 - 13:18
  Re: To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-11-2016 - 21:07
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Max Wyss 04-12-2016 - 00:31
  New rail systems hunt engr 04-12-2016 - 12:28
  Re: New rail systems hunt Max Wyss 04-12-2016 - 14:54
  Re: New rail systems hunt synonymouse 04-12-2016 - 21:09
  Re: New rail systems hunt mook 04-12-2016 - 21:18
  Re: New rail systems hunt Max Wyss 04-13-2016 - 00:36
  Re: New rail systems hunt Dr Zarkoff 04-13-2016 - 10:59
  Re: New rail systems hunt Max Wyss 04-13-2016 - 11:27
  Re: New rail systems hunt engr 04-13-2016 - 11:29
  Re: New rail systems hunt Max Wyss 04-13-2016 - 16:51
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Jon 04-11-2016 - 10:29
  Re: To hell with broad gauge david vartanoff 04-11-2016 - 11:19
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Espee99 04-12-2016 - 08:30
  Re: To hell with broad gauge OldPoleBurner 04-12-2016 - 10:49
  Re: To hell with broad gauge fKrock 04-12-2016 - 11:39
  Re: To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-12-2016 - 12:29
  Re: To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-12-2016 - 12:35
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Max Wyss 04-12-2016 - 14:59
  Re: To hell with broad gauge OldPoleBurner 04-12-2016 - 20:04
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Jim Speaker 04-12-2016 - 12:53
  Re: To hell with broad gauge synonymouse 04-12-2016 - 14:22
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Max Wyss 04-12-2016 - 15:05
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Commuter 04-12-2016 - 18:05
  Nice to have some brevity here OldPoleBurner 04-12-2016 - 20:15
  Re: To hell with broad gauge mook 04-12-2016 - 21:23
  Re: To hell with broad gauge mook 04-12-2016 - 21:24
  Re: To hell with broad gauge Tee Hee 04-13-2016 - 09:24
  Re: To hell with broad gauge George Andrews 04-13-2016 - 20:51


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 ********  **     **   *******   **     **  **        
    **      **   **   **     **  **     **  **    **  
    **       ** **    **     **  **     **  **    **  
    **        ***      ********  **     **  **    **  
    **       ** **           **   **   **   ********* 
    **      **   **   **     **    ** **          **  
    **     **     **   *******      ***           **  
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com