Re: Lac-Mégantic air brake factors
Author: Burr Wilson
Date: 07-16-2013 - 09:44

Reporting by news media informs the general public that shutdown of a locomotive engine (by firefighters on the scene) caused train brakes to become released. It's implied that a locomotive was no longer keeping up its main reservoir air supply, and therefore the entire train lost its air brakes and subsequently rolled away. I disagree.
As you professional and casual railroaders here can attest, that's not how the air brake system on locomotives and cars functions. There's a critical difference between "straight" brakes and "Westinghouse" brakes, as described in a Wikipedia article entitled Railway air brake, [en.wikipedia.org] (which the news media and general public would have little knowledge about).
Leading up to this tragic incident, in less than one hour 70 cars and 5 locos released and rolled away - for me, this doesn't add up as a slow loss of locomotive main reservoir pressure. Whether or not the locomotive's main reservoir bled off, that's not what was holding the train and its cars against the grade ... train braking effort would have been initiated from a service application made while stopping the train, perhaps a 20 pound reduction of train line air pressure, resulting in car brake pistons being actuated with air supplied from each car's reservoir. Hand brakes on locomotives and cars (subsequently applied in sufficient quantity as prescribed by operating rules) would have provided another static braking force at the wheels, effectively a parallel or backup brake system to hold the train in place when "bottled air" in the car reservoirs eventually bleeds off.
It's been reported that handbrakes had been applied on the locos, not the cars, so apparently bottled air in the train was temporarily keeping things from rolling off the mountain when the train was tied down. "Leaky" (or any professional railroaders familiar with air brakes), how long might it take for typical freight cars (with proper COTS work) to eventually lose charge of air in each car's air reservoir?



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  Lac-Mégantic Speculation 07-10-2013 - 09:28
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Shortline Sammie 07-10-2013 - 13:25
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Ed Workman 07-10-2013 - 15:17
  Re: Lac-Mégantic up833 07-10-2013 - 19:04
  Re: Lac-Mégantic More Speculation 07-11-2013 - 05:16
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Bonjour 07-11-2013 - 05:49
  Re: Lac-Mégantic OPRRMS 07-11-2013 - 09:38
  Re: Lac-Mégantic OPRRMS 07-11-2013 - 10:24
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Thoughts to ponder 07-11-2013 - 06:59
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Formerly A. Bureacrat 07-11-2013 - 07:53
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Ed Workman 07-11-2013 - 08:27
  Re: Lac-Mégantic J 07-11-2013 - 09:56
  Re: Lac-Mégantic R Ruiz 07-11-2013 - 18:44
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Ernest H. Robl 07-11-2013 - 21:13
  Re: Lac-Mégantic ron 07-12-2013 - 08:37
  Lac-Mégantic J 07-12-2013 - 09:21
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Fred 07-12-2013 - 15:59
  Re: Lac-Mégantic crunch 07-12-2013 - 19:15
  Re: Lac-Mégantic theconductor 07-13-2013 - 10:32
  Re: Lac-Mégantic Michael Mahoney 07-13-2013 - 17:17
  Re: Lac-Mégantic ron 07-13-2013 - 21:19
  Re: Lac-Mégantic SP5103 07-13-2013 - 23:13
  Re: Lac-Mégantic ron 07-12-2013 - 16:07
  Re: Lac-Mégantic remote control factors Burr Wilson 07-15-2013 - 09:56
  Re: Lac-Mégantic remote control factors jbbane 07-15-2013 - 17:04
  Re: Lac-Mégantic remote control factors Leaky 07-15-2013 - 21:48
  Re: Lac-Mégantic air brake factors Burr Wilson 07-16-2013 - 09:44
  Re: Lac-Mégantic air brake factors Dr Zarkoff 07-16-2013 - 11:46
  National Post graphic Alan Yetta 07-17-2013 - 02:38
  Re: Lac-Mégantic air brake factors Detective Columbo 07-17-2013 - 21:33
  Re: Lac-Mégantic air brake factors OPRRMS 07-18-2013 - 09:51
  Re: Lac-Mégantic - insufficient brake force applied Brakeman 07-19-2013 - 14:26
  Re: Lac-Mégantic - TSB letters Saboteur 07-19-2013 - 20:40


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **    **  **          ******   ********  **     ** 
 ***   **  **    **   **    **     **      **   **  
 ****  **  **    **   **           **       ** **   
 ** ** **  **    **   **           **        ***    
 **  ****  *********  **           **       ** **   
 **   ***        **   **    **     **      **   **  
 **    **        **    ******      **     **     ** 
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com