Steam locomotives and black smoke
Author: Margaret (SP fan)
Date: 12-14-2015 - 13:19

John West ---
That is a very nice photo!

The smoke can be PhotoShopped out and replaced with
a nice plume of white (or grayish) condensing steam.

I, too, DETEST all that thick black smoke. It was
quite justifiably a huge No-No in the steam era because
it both wastes fuel (that black smoke some of you love
so much is unburned fuel) and makes the engine --
temporarily -- a poor steamer (because putting more fuel
into the firebox than the engine can burn soots up the
flues and tubes, and, because soot is a pretty good
insulator, it inhibits heat transfer from the interior
of those tubes and flues to the water in the boiler).

Operators of steam locomotives who unnecessarily made
them smoke have been mis-educating the public for the
past 80 years.

Very few people now realize that steam locomotives do
NOT need to make thick clouds of black smoke in order
to run. To give one example,the SP required its oil-
burning steam locomotives to run with only a slight
brownish haze above the stack. And even a coal-burner
can run with a a pretty clear stack, even when working
hard -- if she had both good coaland an excellent fireman.
For a good example of this, lease look at videos of the
NKP 765 going UP the grade around Horseshow Curve with a
heavy train. It was cold then, and she only made a
beautiful plume of white condensing steam -- it wasn't
even grey! And, yes, she WAS doing ALL the work! (That
is a point of pride to her crew.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j4bGc3UsMpg

Long ago, qwhen movie film was very expensive, steam
locomotive crews willingly made black smoke for
photograhers, because showing that a train had a
long plume of black smoke was then the only way those
photographers could show that that train was moving.

But that was then. This is now.

IMO, it is way past time to kick the smoke habit --before
it kicks all of us who love steam locomotives where we can't
stand to be kicked -- by creating public pressure to stop
operating “those dirty steam locomotives”.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  Phraud-o-freight John West 12-13-2015 - 16:56
  Re: Phraud-o-freight John West 12-13-2015 - 16:59
  Re: Phraud-o-freight Geob 12-13-2015 - 17:05
  Re: Phraud-o-freight F 12-13-2015 - 17:33
  Re: Phraud-o-freight Phraud Indeed! 12-14-2015 - 06:42
  Phraud Indeed John West 12-14-2015 - 09:17
  Steam locomotives and black smoke Margaret (SP fan) 12-14-2015 - 13:19
  Re: Steam locomotives and black smoke David Dewey 12-16-2015 - 01:21
  Re: Steam locomotives and black smoke mook 12-16-2015 - 09:19
  Re: Phraud-o-freight Chris Walker 12-14-2015 - 17:05
  Re: Phraud-o-freight Nudge 12-14-2015 - 18:58
  Re: Phraud-o-freight Terry 12-15-2015 - 16:08


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **    **  ********  **     **  ********         ** 
  **  **      **     **     **  **     **        ** 
   ****       **     **     **  **     **        ** 
    **        **     **     **  **     **        ** 
    **        **     **     **  **     **  **    ** 
    **        **     **     **  **     **  **    ** 
    **        **      *******   ********    ******  
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com