Re: The media
Author: Sam Richards
Date: 10-06-2016 - 14:49

Speaking as both a railfan and a journalist, I agree with about 95 percent of what Justin Franz said in his opinion piece, and I thought the piece was wonderful overall. I'm known in my newsroom as the "train expert," and I've had to tweak my colleagues' stories occasionally so they don't say "chuffed" or "locomotive driver," or call Union Pacific a "train company," and so on. And I cringe when I see language like that in stories about trains in other newspapers or on TV. But it's true that, unless you report almost exclusively on transportation (few of us do, certainly not me), reporters just don't have that knowledge, and aren't going to "look it up on the Internet" in advance should a major train story land in their lap sometime in the future. If there's a major derailment at 2 p.m. on a Tuesday and we have to get a story online ASAP and ready for print by 8 p.m., there isn't much time to bone up on the jargon of the rail industry. I think that for stories like that NWP tank car mess -- the TV report was not only one-sided, it was ignorant -- you should take longer to get facts straight. That story wasn't a we-need-it-in-five-minutes scenario. Based on comments I've seen elsewhere on this discussion board, some not so long ago, it's clear some people have little understanding of modern journalism. The beast, indeed, must be fed, be it TV, newspapers or radio. The deadline scramble, with varying levels of information from rail companies at varying degrees of timeliness, can result in mistakes, sometimes goofy looking ones. But "non-deadline" pieces, like that NWP tank car flap, deserve better coverage than they often get, and that often means just asking a few more carefully considered questions (and getting all sides).



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  The media Charles Stookey 10-05-2016 - 18:37
  Re: The media Tundraboomer 10-05-2016 - 19:00
  Re: The media mook 10-05-2016 - 20:25
  Re: The media clipper841 10-05-2016 - 20:46
  Re: The media Copy19 10-05-2016 - 20:49
  Re: The media Carol L Voss 10-05-2016 - 21:25
  Re: The media Katy Lied 10-05-2016 - 21:57
  Re: The media The Odd Duck 10-05-2016 - 23:27
  Re: The media clipper841 10-05-2016 - 23:54
  Re: The media fkrock 10-06-2016 - 08:55
  Re: The media Sam Richards 10-06-2016 - 14:49
  Re: The media Ed Workman 10-07-2016 - 08:30
  Re: The media Copy19 10-07-2016 - 15:16
  One more thing Copy19 10-07-2016 - 15:35
  Re: One more thing Sam Richards 10-08-2016 - 09:48
  Re: One more thing Copy19 10-08-2016 - 10:20
  Re: One more thing mook 10-08-2016 - 11:38
  Re: One more thing; and another mook 10-08-2016 - 11:47
  Re: One more thing; and another Sam Richards 10-08-2016 - 22:43


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **    **  **    **  **         ********  ******** 
  **  **   **   **   **    **   **           **    
   ****    **  **    **    **   **           **    
    **     *****     **    **   ******       **    
    **     **  **    *********  **           **    
    **     **   **         **   **           **    
    **     **    **        **   ********     **    
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com