Re: CA HSR Update-Planning History and Plan B.....?
Author: No
Date: 08-21-2018 - 18:04

No matter how you get from Northern to Southern California, you have to cross some faults. All of them are active, more or less. But:

* Competent engineers can design things to 1) not fall down in the maximum credible earthquake, and 2) for probable earthquakes, be repairable in fairly short order. Even PB has some competent engineers, though I'd prefer some other firm due to corporate overhead and history.

* Alignments can be laid out, and have been, to cross major faults at grade. That makes the inevitable (on megaproject time scales, with construction and operation lasting 100 years or more) earthquake more manageable.

Geology is not a project killer. It's something to design and plan around. Even Bob2's tunnel has to deal with several faults, but not the S.A. (should be on the surface by then). Will the others move? Maybe; on a geological time scale, certainly, but on a human time scale it's a crapshoot with the odds in favor of a human alive today not experiencing a big one from more than a few sources. There are other tunnels through both the San Gabriel and the Tehachapi (both near Tejon and near Tehachapi/Mojave) mountains, too. With competent engineering and construction, they should survive for a long time unless everything comes up snake-eyes at once (do you feel lucky?). So your job, as a citizen, is to make sure the politicians you think you can influence do what they can to ensure competence in planning, design, and construction. HSR so far has been a bad example of that. Consider it a challenge to make Plan B better. And your job, as an individual living in earthquake country, is to be prepared and carry on with life.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  CA HSR Update JOHN 08-19-2018 - 07:06
  Re: CA HSR Update My Name 08-19-2018 - 11:43
  Re: CA HSR Update Porky Pig 08-19-2018 - 12:13
  Re: CA HSR Update M. Harris 08-19-2018 - 17:44
  Re: CA HSR Update Carol L Voss 08-19-2018 - 17:46
  Re: CA HSR Update synonymouse 08-19-2018 - 18:46
  Re: CA HSR Update Clem 08-19-2018 - 20:33
  Re: CA HSR Update Clem 08-19-2018 - 20:30
  Re: CA HSR Update Commenter 08-19-2018 - 21:31
  Re: CA HSR Update Carol L Voss 08-19-2018 - 22:51
  Re: CA HSR Update? SS/DD at the Runaway Money Train BOB2 08-19-2018 - 23:48
  Re: CA HSR Update? SS/DD at the Runaway Money Train synonymouse 08-19-2018 - 23:54
  Re: CA HSR Update? SS/DD at the Runaway Money Train Joe Magruder 08-20-2018 - 03:29
  Re: CA HSR Update? SS/DD at the Runaway Money Train No 08-20-2018 - 09:27
  Re: CA HSR Update? SS/DD at the Runaway Money Train Bob 08-20-2018 - 11:25
  Re: CA HSR Update Commenter 08-20-2018 - 11:37
  Re: CA HSR Update Cprr 08-20-2018 - 15:40
  Re: CA HSR Update Commenter 08-20-2018 - 15:43
  Re: CA HSR Update No 08-20-2018 - 18:16
  Re: CA HSR Update Commenter 08-20-2018 - 20:31
  Re: CA HSR Update Commenter 08-20-2018 - 22:41
  Re: CA HSR Update Clem 08-20-2018 - 22:09
  Re: CA HSR Update No 08-21-2018 - 07:58
  Re: CA HSR Update-Half assed justtifications from the ususal suspects BOB2 08-21-2018 - 08:40
  Re: CA HSR Update-Half assed justtifications from the ususal suspects synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 10:05
  Re: CA HSR Update-Half assed justtifications from the ususal suspects BOB2 08-21-2018 - 11:00
  Re: CA HSR Update-Half assed justtifications from the ususal suspects synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 11:21
  Re: CA HSR Update-Of tunnels, taxpayer dollars, and user needs....? BOB2 08-21-2018 - 12:31
  Re: CA HSR Update-Of tunnels, taxpayer dollars, and user needs....? synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 14:18
  Re: CA HSR Update-Of tunnels and the evil earth quake conspiracy...? BOB2 08-21-2018 - 14:34
  Re: CA HSR Update-Of tunnels and the evil earth quake conspiracy...? No 08-21-2018 - 15:55
  Re: CA HSR Update-Of tunnels, taxpayer dollars, and user needs....? No 08-21-2018 - 15:51
  Re: CA HSR Update-Half assed justtifications from the ususal suspects No 08-21-2018 - 15:48
  Re: CA HSR Update-Planning History and Plan B.....? BOB2 08-21-2018 - 16:58
  Re: CA HSR Update-Planning History and Plan B.....? synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 17:21
  Re: CA HSR Update-Planning History and Plan B.....? synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 17:25
  Geology??? OMG???? Will we fall off into the ocean...??? BOB2 08-21-2018 - 17:31
  Re: Geology??? OMG???? Will we fall off into the ocean...??? synonymouse 08-21-2018 - 19:00
  Re: CA HSR Update-Planning History and Plan B.....? No 08-21-2018 - 18:04
  and a side note for the Mouse No 08-21-2018 - 18:27
  Re: and a side note for the Mouse, as though it would matter? BOB2 08-21-2018 - 18:39
  Re: CA HSR Update Tunnel Security Concerns ? Mighty Mouse is on the way....... BOB2 08-21-2018 - 18:07
  Re: CA HSR Update Tunnel Security Concerns ? Mighty Mouse is on the way....... Kr 08-22-2018 - 08:26
  Re: CA HSR Update Tunnel Security Concerns ? Mighty Mouse is on the way....... Kr 08-22-2018 - 08:26


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **     **  ********   **    **  ********  ******** 
 **     **  **     **  **   **   **           **    
 **     **  **     **  **  **    **           **    
 *********  ********   *****     ******       **    
 **     **  **     **  **  **    **           **    
 **     **  **     **  **   **   **           **    
 **     **  ********   **    **  ********     **    
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com