Re: Caltrain EMU's ????
Author: mook
Date: 01-19-2014 - 15:12

LA's Rotems were designed specifically for crash energy management in a push-pull system. They were pioneers because they had to be after several bad wrecks that might have been more survivable with CEM cars - though head-on with another train at 50+ mph is probably not survivable for those up front anyway. Metrolink's problems were bigger than just ordinary grade crossing wrecks.

EMUs and DMUs designed for use without restrictions are considered locomotives by FRA and have to meet the same crash standards. CEM helps to handle that without grossly increasing the train weight.

Grade crossing wrecks even with cab cars aren't usually a huge problem for the train, unless somehow a high-speed derailment occurs. CEM can help, but US CEM is designed more for train-train collisions than for grade crossing hits. Wrecks like Amtrak in Nevada, where a vehicle runs into the side of the train, are basically unmanageable - you just have to hope that the hit isn't in a place that will cause derailment or start a fire in the train; and whether or not the train is EMU doesn't really matter.

Volpe (US DOT's research center) did a bunch of testing in the early-mid 2000s that led to the Rotem cars and use of CEM. See for instance:

[onlinepubs.trb.org]
[ntl.bts.gov]

And for locomotives too:

[ntl.bts.gov]

And of course the obligatory Youtube video of the crash tests:

[www.youtube.com]

Cheers.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. HUTCH 7.62 01-18-2014 - 22:40
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 04:20
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. Ed Workman 01-19-2014 - 07:56
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 08:34
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. HUTCH 7.62 01-19-2014 - 08:47
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Jon 01-19-2014 - 09:02
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Rich Hunn 01-19-2014 - 09:26
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 10:24
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Margaret (SP fan) 01-19-2014 - 11:29
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 11:58
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Chris Walker 01-19-2014 - 22:41
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Rich Hunn 01-20-2014 - 09:27
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. mook 01-20-2014 - 09:48
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Rich Hunn 01-20-2014 - 10:02
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. mook 01-20-2014 - 10:08
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. HUTCH 7.62 01-20-2014 - 10:22
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Max Wyss 01-20-2014 - 12:01
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. mook 01-20-2014 - 15:04
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 10:17
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. fkrock 01-19-2014 - 11:28
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? :( Margaret (SP fan) 01-19-2014 - 11:59
  Crash protection Eugene 01-19-2014 - 12:06
  Re: Crash protection synonymouse 01-19-2014 - 12:23
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? :( Max Wyss 01-19-2014 - 12:25
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? Margaret (SP fan) 01-19-2014 - 13:49
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? mook 01-19-2014 - 15:12
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? Margaret (SP fan) 01-19-2014 - 16:05
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I get it. Brian 01-19-2014 - 12:28
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? OK I get it now Ed Workman 01-19-2014 - 16:33
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. BOB R 01-19-2014 - 20:12
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. John Bromley 01-20-2014 - 12:07
  Re: Caltrain EMU's ???? I don't get it. Mike Swanson 01-23-2014 - 18:15


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **     **  **     **  **      **        **   ******  
 **     **  **     **  **  **  **        **  **    ** 
 **     **  **     **  **  **  **        **  **       
 *********  **     **  **  **  **        **  **       
 **     **   **   **   **  **  **  **    **  **       
 **     **    ** **    **  **  **  **    **  **    ** 
 **     **     ***      ***  ***    ******    ******  
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com