Re: electric trains
Author: John Bruce
Date: 08-16-2008 - 07:34

I don't see the efficiency in a 400-600 mile strech of electrified track. What's the cost of changing engines at each end of the stretch, as well as the presumably duplicative rosters -- if you had the line between Amarillo and Winslow electrified, say, wouldn't you need three sets of locos to haul a train from Chicago to LA? Whereas now, a single set of BNSF power often runs through between Newark on CR shared assets and LA. That has got to mean greater investment and maintenance in a larger absolute number of locos. You are adding a complication to operation no matter what you do, and if anything at all goes wrong, you'll need extra locos to account for late trains, for instance.

In fact, the trend has certainly been to eliminate intermediate stretches of electrified track for freight operation. Do you seriously think that if the Milwaukee Road had closed its non-electrified gap the electrification would have lasted any longer than it did?

I'm not sure if Europe is a good analogy. I believe the railroads there, as state enterprises, electrified in some measure to provide predictable load for the state-owned electric utilities. Also, I believe there are often major differences between electric freight and passenger locos in Europe, just as there are between freight and passenger diesels here. Just look at the difference between a P42 and an ES44 -- it goes way beyond HEP. And this leaves out the electric locomotives designed into ICE and TGV type trains.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  electric trains mook 08-15-2008 - 20:41
  Re: electric trains mike 08-15-2008 - 21:35
  Re: electric trains Ernest H. Robl 08-16-2008 - 05:56
  Re: electric trains John Bruce 08-16-2008 - 07:34
  Re: electric trains Ernest H. Robl 08-16-2008 - 17:10
  Re: electric trains Ernest H. Robl 08-16-2008 - 19:31
  Re: electric railroads? BOB2 08-16-2008 - 08:11
  Re: electric railroads? John Bruce 08-16-2008 - 09:40
  Re: electric railroads? Butler 08-16-2008 - 10:12
  Re: electric railroads? John Bruce 08-16-2008 - 13:08
  Re: electric railroads? P.Kepler 08-16-2008 - 10:43
  Re: electric railroads? OldPoleBurner 08-16-2008 - 13:58
  Re: electric railroads? P.Kepler 08-16-2008 - 14:25
  Re: electric railroads? John Bruce 08-16-2008 - 14:35
  "Electric tender" Ernest H. Robl 08-16-2008 - 17:44
  Clearance issues Ernest H. Robl 08-16-2008 - 17:22
  Re: Clearance issues DzNtz 08-16-2008 - 23:13
  Re: electric trains Dave Smith 08-16-2008 - 11:33
  Re: electric trains Rich Hunn 08-16-2008 - 16:26
  Re: electric trains Mike Swanson 08-16-2008 - 16:46
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Dave Smith 08-16-2008 - 23:20
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel BOB2 08-17-2008 - 08:32
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel g 08-17-2008 - 10:04
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel P.Kepler 08-17-2008 - 10:19
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Dave Smith 08-17-2008 - 12:02
  Alternative Steam Locomotive Design. Jeff A. 08-17-2008 - 12:48
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel John Bruce 08-17-2008 - 13:00
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Dave Smith 08-18-2008 - 10:01
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel John Bruce 08-18-2008 - 10:41
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel GRRR 08-18-2008 - 11:50
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel mook 08-18-2008 - 16:50
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel E 08-19-2008 - 14:52
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Dave Smith 08-19-2008 - 19:15
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Jacob Marley 08-19-2008 - 21:27
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel E 08-19-2008 - 22:52
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel e 08-19-2008 - 22:51
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Earl Pitts 08-20-2008 - 10:02
  Re: steam maintenance vs diesel Mike Swanson 08-20-2008 - 18:52
  Re: electric trains The Montezuma Yardmaster 08-21-2008 - 19:04
  Re: electric trains fkrock 08-21-2008 - 21:20


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **     **  **     **        **  **    **  **     ** 
  **   **   **     **        **  ***   **  **     ** 
   ** **    **     **        **  ****  **  **     ** 
    ***     **     **        **  ** ** **  ********* 
   ** **     **   **   **    **  **  ****  **     ** 
  **   **     ** **    **    **  **   ***  **     ** 
 **     **     ***      ******   **    **  **     ** 
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com