Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile
Author: fkrock
Date: 06-26-2011 - 08:55

Sorry gang but film remain superior to digital. Yes, digital is easier. If you are not satisfied with the results you can correct the problem in most cases and reshoot on the spot. So for probably 99% of railfan photos digital is adequate.

First: Film resolution is many times higher than the best digital imaging devices today, typically equivalent to 18,000 dpi or higher. If you want to enlarge a small detail to study something, the information often is there on film. With digital you will get a pixilated image that reveals little. No digital manipulation will bring out detail that is not on the original.

Second: Film will record a much wider range of light levels than digital. Even though you may not be able to see it on a print, details in full shade or full sun often are on the negative. If you need to see details in full shade, you can make a special print to reveal them.

In railway museum restoration work often we must use old photographs. For example, to determine what type of stove was used in a car, a typical fan 3/4 view shot in full sun was used. A car door was open. On the negative the stove inside the car was visible although it was in deep shade. Thank goodness that was not a digital photo; nothing except black would have been visible inside the car.



Subject Written By Date/Time (PST)
  film hal wanaselja 06-25-2011 - 08:04
  Re: film Marty Bernard 06-25-2011 - 08:31
  Re: film Kyle 06-25-2011 - 09:07
  Re: film Tom Moungovan 06-25-2011 - 09:33
  Re: film Hal 06-25-2011 - 10:53
  Re: film Freericks 06-25-2011 - 11:35
  Re: film L.A.Scrafford 06-25-2011 - 11:49
  Re: film Ernest H. Robl 06-25-2011 - 12:57
  Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile Marty Bernard 06-25-2011 - 19:29
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile Dick Dorn 06-25-2011 - 20:30
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile mook 06-25-2011 - 21:16
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile George Andrews 06-25-2011 - 21:27
  Scanning B&W negs John West 06-25-2011 - 21:35
  Re: Scanning B&W negs WAF 06-26-2011 - 06:10
  Re: Scanning B&W negs Sam Reeves 06-26-2011 - 15:45
  Re: Scanning B&W negs steve Thompson 06-26-2011 - 17:14
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile Steven D. Johnson 06-26-2011 - 07:47
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile mook 06-26-2011 - 13:41
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile Ernest H. Robl 06-26-2011 - 08:13
  Re: Why Digital Trumps Film by a Mile fkrock 06-26-2011 - 08:55
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. THAT guy 06-26-2011 - 09:37
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. John Barnhill 06-26-2011 - 11:11
  Re: Back to the original question Tom Moungovan 06-26-2011 - 12:43
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. njt 06-26-2011 - 13:04
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. John Barnhill 06-26-2011 - 17:46
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. George Andrews 06-26-2011 - 17:48
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. Steve Sloan 06-26-2011 - 18:11
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. Steven D. Johnson 06-26-2011 - 22:52
  Re: Why Digital will betray you. Freericks 06-26-2011 - 19:58
  Digital will NOT betray you. a younger railfan 06-26-2011 - 23:18
  Re: Digital will NOT betray you. Steve Thompson 06-27-2011 - 05:01
  Re: Digital will NOT betray you. Freericks 06-27-2011 - 05:33
  Re: more opinions... Severe Duty 06-27-2011 - 08:16
  Re: more opinions... Steve Thompson 06-27-2011 - 09:17
  Re: more opinions... mook 06-27-2011 - 12:41
  Re: more opinions... Digitial to Film 06-27-2011 - 14:23
  Re: more opinions... Freericks 06-27-2011 - 14:24
  Re: Graflex Severe Duty 06-27-2011 - 21:37
  Re: more opinions... Severe Duty 06-27-2011 - 21:52
  Re: more opinions... Marv. 06-27-2011 - 16:31
  Re: more opinions... Tom Moungovan 06-27-2011 - 18:23
  Re: more opinions... Freericks 06-27-2011 - 20:52


Go to: Message ListSearch
Subject: 
Your Name: 
Spam prevention:
Please, enter the code that you see below in the input field. This is for blocking bots that try to post this form automatically.
 **     **  **     **  **     **   ******    **       
 **     **  **     **  **     **  **    **   **       
 **     **  **     **  **     **  **         **       
 **     **  *********  *********  **   ****  **       
  **   **   **     **  **     **  **    **   **       
   ** **    **     **  **     **  **    **   **       
    ***     **     **  **     **   ******    ******** 
This message board is maintained by:Altamont Press
You can send us an email at altamontpress1@gmail.com